The next problem is way worse: Not every dino is added to the library, even if the program marks them green and says, they are. Please note that the extraction for imprinted creatures may not work always, as the game sometimes "forgets" to increase some st. Hi, you need to have loaded the correct ocr-config-file. Not affiliated with Studio Wildcard All rights reserved. But it does only check this for the next generation. I thought about this for a while. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. The stats will be updated. ARK. Having a weird problem since the last couple of builds that I've just put up with up until now, but I guess you should know about it. Then put the library file into a Dropbox folder and share this folder with your tribe mates. Ark Breeding || How To - Smart Breeding App || TimmyCarbineIn this video I show you how to setup and use the Ark Smart Breeding App in order to keep track of breeding dinos in Ark.I cover a very small section of the program; the extraction and the library tabs, but also how to diagnose issues you may have when extracting stats. Hey Cad, I'm just curious as to what the breeding value is meant to represent when your taming/tamed a dino, never really paid much mind to it till now haha. Hello everyone, I've been watching some breeding videos on YouTube cause I want to begin some serious mass-breeding, I've one doubt : should I imprint every baby or not? This is a newer feature so head over to the GitHub discussion if you have anything to add. The wiki now uses this data heavily, as well as Beacon and probably other tools we dont know about. Probably an interesting mathematical problem, and I'm sure that could be simplified a lot. If you know Taming-Effectiveness or Imprint, you can enter that as well. cad, February 29, 2016 in General Discussion, I might just be using the app wrong, By when using OCR it only tracks the Torpor and Weight. It is sometimes disheartening to myself to have spent hours testing and researching an issue, so I could make a proper suggestion to the developers with reproducible steps, specific variable names, and other information regarding the bug, only to see update after update not address it (still looking at the Troodonisms). Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). It would have been swell to have maybe just 100 mods we needed to support, all of which just extracted smoothly, didnt have conflicting configurations, and had amazing mod developers like Lethal of the Dino Storage mod, and so many other developers that Ive worked with. If there are no yellow but only green stats, the animal will be saved to the library immediately using the settings above. For that follow the links on the right side. She has over 12k hours experience in the game and her main interest is the complex breeding mechanic in ARK. I "reinstalled" the breeding tool, played ark in windowed/fullscreen and put the breeding tool folder in different locations on my computer but still it wont work. 2022 was the year of AI. Update ARK Survival Evolved 7. Seehttps://github.com/cadon/ARKStatsExtractor/wiki/OCR for more infos. But this is not the end of the story. . Also it wants to name Ankylo to "AnL7Io". Checking my xml file it's 1.26MB in size, stats from the status bar in ASB below: Hi, I've never tested the app with so many creatures. I added a colour region to one of my Thylas in ASB and saved it, however when it saved, the colour region jumped to a different cat in the list (the top in the list if that makes any difference) and not the one I set it on (and yeah, I'm sure I did it on the right cat in the first place lol). Game open in first screen and program open in second. Is it just simply a case of clearing out a load of the old no longer relevant (i.e. K3nzie Nov 20, 2018 @ 3:20am. Founder & Director, cutting edge science based Agri-biotechnology companies, in India, Cambridge, UK, Ireland and USA. That was the most impressive part of ASB to me. I would really like to have this feature . Very few people knew that behind the scenes, coldino and I were working on a purely web based version of ASB. second, I can't extract values from in game UI on a dino. I studied documentation on the assumed equations it was based off of. Increase Virtual RAM 3. The new inventory doesn't show any info about the current maturing-progress anymore (before it could be calculated by using the weight of the baby). With multiple monitors it probably also will work if you don't enable the overlay, but just go to the taming-tab in the tool and then tell the tool the species and level. I would really like to have this feature working :(, I have recently downloaded this appI like the OCR feature but it doesnt work for meam having the exact same issue as @Maximo101 Can you please fix this?? Using ARK Smart Breeding.exe P6: 5b19fd0a to your account, I have looked in the help and this site and can't find anything regarding this type of issue. Ark 1 was not without its challenges, but I think aside from the bugs in Arks code (Troodonisms, etc. I find in most cases, it just misreads (or omits) a few numbers, and correcting those and recalculating usually fixes things. In the beginning a lot of feedback was that people didnt understand how to use the app. To this day, Im still incredibly proud of the work I did on the extractor and really wish that everyone could have seen coldinos vision for the app (I have no design abilities) and the effort we put into it to ensure everything just worked. We can do this together . Once your ASB is set up properly, you can create a multiplier file and share it with the people on your server! Redownloadit or look for the runtimes you are missing. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Not affiliated with Studio Wildcard Which update do you mean, or which feature do you expect to be released? Breeding and hatching settings are not working Dear forum members, for some time now we have been creating and maintaining new ways to help game server admins with questions and problems as quickly as possible, e.g. In fact, I never really had a vision of what this app should be. The values in Smart Breeding for that are not yet updated. This is a testament to the dedication he has to the community and how wonderful our community is. If you like what I do, please support me on Ko-fi! Its quite a daunting task to think about recreating as much as we have for Ark 1, so well have to take it one step at a time once we know more about the game and what tools people will need. At first there were only a couple of species included in this StatsExtractor app. Let me know if you need anything from me. Click Extra data and that gives you the chance to download or update your creature images. The used framework (WinForms) is pretty old and especially with flexible layouts or styling (e.g. It seems the mechanism of the tool of taking a screenshot does not always use the set resolution. It always add 14 on dmg example: it has 400% dmg the calculator makes 14400% If all went fine, you can scroll down and add the creature to your library. Event Name: APPCRASH I know there are tons of goals with this, and some of your requests might end up on cutting room floor. I dont think any of us expect ASB to get this big. It was about 6 months or a year after I left that server that I decided to give back to ASB. The Carchar is challenging because of its size and breeding timers. Its a neat little software that helps you to archive the stats, colors and infos around your tames, and it helps you to progress with your breeding by giving you breeding suggestions. Dododex has 35k ratings on the App Store with a rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. From the ground up. The right side is critical for the timers to be correct. Its almost 7 years ago, I cant really tell. Make sure you have the server settings/any changed imprinting settings accurate in Breeder first or you'll get some wonky results Yolie001 2 yr. ago Is not too difficult mate, go into the settings and set a folder where ark has to export the files too. While playing on a PvE server and also editing on the official wiki, we were always eager to understand the mechanics behind newly added features to describe them precisely on the wiki. It can be different to the current stat because of some boni the offspring could get (e.g. Download either the zip-file or the .exe file. Ugh, Scan this QR code to download the app now. With the release of the Carcharodontosaurus I decided to write an article about how I prepare a new breeding base and set up new breeders in order to start mutating a new dinos. Faulting package-relative application ID: Fault bucket 2232510505958811364, type 1 My High School's motto was "Vel Primus, Vel cum Primis," "Either First, or With the First" I live this motto. It's surely one of those would be the reason. The dev of ARK Smart breeding made it easy for you to import those stats. Make sure all the multipliers are set correctly if you're on an unofficial server. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. It seems like it's showing you the best pair to breed but is that as far as it goes? That way you can keep the Pedigree useful. Did you make sure the selected species was correct? But I could really use some help, Forgot to note the stats of a creature before leveling up? Breeding is a feature of ARK: Survival Evolved that allows players to breed improved creatures through Eggs with non-mammals and gestation with mammals. will give it another go later tonight. Once I have better info about these tabs, I will update this section. The community have developed some great mods and tools for Ark 1, but better access to live game data for users and server owners would bring even more opportunitiesand massively help ASB users of course. and our Eggs do not have an owner, so it's possible to steal eggs laid by other survivors' creatures. P8: 00454dfd A way to fix this is to cryo the creature once, uncryo it and then export it again. Wed welcome small changes, new ideas, even big reworksjust no dumbing down, please! to be honest I only tried about twice a while ago. It's a complex process. Page 1 of 2. A lot of settings in here are down to personal preference and to how you will use ASB. If the imprinting-progress is corrected by the tool, one of the beforementioned multipliers is not correct for that creature, the tool always chooses the nearest possible value. Manual The configs are in the folder json/ and start with `ocr_` followed by the resolution and the UI-scaling. Thank you. This will get you to where to download everything you need. If the mod is not available in ASB then you can suggest it via the Discord. Again, very few things in Ark 1 were easy to support. At this point it would be the perfect time to test importing a creature and if everything is set up correctly. Is your native resolution of the monitor different to 1920 x 1080? The Info Graphic settings are also only important if you use them. Food, DMG, Speed and Torpor are all marked red; even though this is marked as "Wild" or "Wild-Creature Check". Extracts possible levelups of creatures to get the values for breeding. Excellent knowledge and experience of new plant breeding techniques (NBT) to solve industry problems and to create new crop varieties with novel traits for food, feed, alternative protein market . Sign up for a new account in our community. While Wildcard has made efforts recently (last few years now) to extend employees into the public space (content creators, modders, wiki, support programs), I dont feel that its quite enough. The OCR now is independent from the resolution, as long as you have a correct config-file. Unfortunately the old software library it is written on (WinForms) and the sheer amount of UI make that an impractical job that nobody has dared to tackle. Even after selling more than 50 Argentavis, hand raised by myself while maintaining a full time job, I realized I needed help, but I just couldnt trust anyone. It just says "Extraction failed. The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: Hi, the OCR-feature does not work very well, especially in resolutions other than 1920x1080. Hi K3nzie, Im on the similar boat with you on this, Been following this guide on breeding rexes for super stats, Not sure if this'll help or not, but It's helped me and i hardly know anything of breeding Imprinting or leveling your dino's has 0 effect on the stats being passed down to the next generation. i just found your program and was eager to test it. With the calculations and library tracking features of ASB, I ended up selling over 200 Argentavis before giving up on the server. Am I playing with Single player settings? But I targeted my Argentavis towards health, damage, and carry capacity. Copyright 2022 Studio Wildcard. I will try the manual screenshot method later on today, thanks. If it's not doing anything, you still can type in the values manually. All rights reserved. So far the news for Ark 2 and indeed the whole Ark ecosystem has only been exciting, and shows a great leap in maturity for the company. The good thing about it? Red means that there are no possibilities that these stats are correct with the import you just did. You have to open the inventory of a creature you want to read the values from, Alt-Tab to the tool and click the button. Then I mate those animals and check how close the offspring is to the perfect stats and then keep the ones that are very close. It lists all your Eggs / Gestations and Babies with according timers and needed food. Plow for taking their time to answer these questions and giving us a look behind the scenes how a project like ARK Smart Breeding starts out of an idea and how even the smallest idea can become a big project. It has to be one of the six free maps because you either dont have the Season Passes or your friends dont have them, but how to choose which map is []. Hi, it's probably related to an update of the mod classic flyers. He also didnt want to enter all the stats by hand (exporting dino stats wasnt a thing back then), so he just built the OCR functionality and also added the overlay, so you could see the extracted levels directly in the game when viewing the inventory of a creature without even tabbing out of the game. Those numbers look kind of extreme for a fresh tame; have you configured Smart Breeding to match your server's settings. With the OCR you can let ASB read the dino values from your screen in case you cant export them, and you dont want to type them either. it is very strenuous to go back and forth entering each value in the stats boxthe OCR feature makes this process very easy..I have a 1440p monitor but even after switching the game to 1080p resolution I cant get the OCR to workcould you please optimize the app for higher than 1920x1080 resolutions..Thank you!! By clicking Sign up for GitHub, you agree to our terms of service and While I was determined to remain peaceful as Ark was an outlet for me to have fun with good players and trash talk with the trolls. Do you have access to your game.ini or gameusersettings.ini? how to use it? ARK Smart Breeding For the game ARK Survival Evolved. Sorry for not replying sooner. The idea is to enable the overlay (the button is on the top-right in the tool, after you enabled the OCR). If you need anything from me to investigate this, just shout. It's OCR isn't perfect in my experience, as can be expected from semi-transparent UI elements; double check the stat numbers it read vs the screenshot itself. Report Id: f3ad99b8-b8a1-417d-96db-1574d50b4032 Rechecking for solution: 0 Not sure if someone already had the same problem, I didn't find any post. The settings can also look overwhelming but dont be scared! So i did. Here you can choose the mods you are using. So even if you never change anything on the right side, they will still import. https://github.com/cadon/ARKStatsExtractor/wiki/OCR, Automatically put in the values so you don't have to write them manually. Faulting process id: 0x3160 It can also not do certain things, and its not always clear if and when the AI is wrong because it just knows so much and sounds so confident even when its [], POV, you just finished the content on The Island and you want to have a new ARK experience and play on a new map. It also incorrectly records the names. Hi @vanghern, sorry for the late reply. I believe we are all impressed with the trailers and information so far, but Im also interested to hear some interviews with the teams (technical interviews are good too). While I personally would love to talk to a developer and discuss the game, Im pretty sure content creators like TiiaAurora have a better chance at that. Here you can look into a specific species you have in your library and then let ASB plan the breeding of your perfect animal. When I click it, it just goes back to ark, then does not re open Ark Smart breeding. if you have any Spyglass Mod that shows the actual Points in each stat, use that spyglass and enter the points directly in the Stat Testing Tab. I'm closing this issue for now, if there are more issues, reopen this one or create a new one. There's also mono that allows to run .NET-applications on other OS like linux, maybe you can install mono on the chromebook (mono-project.com). Highlight 254 / 255 and even / odd is especially important when you want to fully cap a stat or a line. In the end you get one baby, and all the probabilities doesn't matter anymore once you got it, the suggestions are there to make sure you breed the pair that has the highest probability of getting a nice offspring. Even simple things like public CDN access to game assets (e.g. Hide invisible colour regions will disable the view or colour regions that animal does not use. This has the advantage of having always the correct numbers and it also has the color-infos and the parents (if they were imported in the same way). File -> Load additional values -> select classicFlyers.json. Very aggressive, belligerent and relentless, the Titanoboa will pursue and attack most creatures (except other . Newborn creatures are simply claimed (imprinted on) and do not require the usual taming processes associated with wild creatures. The things on the left side are yet again to be set up to your liking. In this room you can request to have your multipliers figured out through maths. It's as though it's completely skipping the Health Value, The extractor still doesn't seem to like handling multiples of 0, Ankylo has 6900 Food value in-game; Extractor wants to extract instead 677. Press "OK" to save the settings. If you run into errors, check if you set up your creature, multipliers correctly and if the creature was cryoed first. So far I just hadnt the motivation/time to rewrite that. When will the new update release ? P10: Attached files: Faulting module name: clr.dll, version: 4.7.3131.0, time stamp: 0x5b19fd0a These settings in the tool have to match the ones on the server when the baby was born, even if the multipliers where changed in the meantime. In the end we found the imprinting is always increased based on specific values and multipliers and implementing this long missed feature was like adding 4 lines of code. The library is where all your creatures are saved and listed. Plow apart from everyone else. In the age of game simplification, please dont simplify the breeding mechanic too far! icons) would remove a significant barrier of entry to developers who want to make good-looking web apps. Unfortunately on the other side of the coin, ASB has grown into quite a complex beast thats hard to extend now. The former alpha tribe ruled the server for 4 months before finally being taken down by new blood. All rights reserved. The first one was NakramR who helped a lot with programming style and who said it would be nice to save and load the levels you had extracted, so you dont lose your work. Im looking forward to what the next installment has to bring to the table. Theoretically there is no limit (only system-dependant like the filesize or overflow-issues), at some point the performance probably is just too bad to use it. I think its a good example how laziness is a great motivator to add new feature to ease the workflow, and also that a lot more is possible with programming than you might first consider. These I have not set up myself, so I cant give any good advice on how to set these up. \\?\C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\WER\Temp\WER62AD.tmp.csv To help with that I started a simple application where you could enter the stat values of a creature and the app would try to solve it and display the according levels. In order to have your software been deemed secure, you will have to get a publisher licence for your software. | Check for Windows Updates 8. Now you can also save your extracted stats in a library, see which creature, Wish there was a way we could extract stats on Xbox, Smart Breeding now supports the extraction of imprinted creatures. Its always nice to have everything that you need to know about your creature on one screen. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America), https://survivetheark.com/index.php?/forums/topic/39942-tool-ark-smart-breeding-extract-breeding-stats-dino-library-pedigree/. Copying to tester / extractor without the Creature-Info: I'll fix that, thanks for noting that. It may be something on my system (in which case I'm very keen to know what as nothing else does this), but ASB works fine while its being actively used, however, leave it idle for any length of time and it crashes the next time you click anything within it. If you don't find a file for your resolution, you can create one yourself, but that needs some work. I'm trying to extract an Ankylo at the moment and there a few things going on with the Extraction that are a little funky. You can try it with other cloud services, but Dropbox is by far the fastest and causes the least problems for me. It simply didnt work when i was playing ark in windowed mode. You would not believe how often that happens.). If anybody is experienced with Ark Smart Breeding I would really appreciate the help. For this you need to load a specific config-file that was made for the resolution and the UI-scaling you use. But ultimately, all that hard work came crashing down after observing significant data usage during a random test we were doing. It does taking into account which stat-combinations are not yet in your library and are probably the ones you want. Properly Place the Storage and RAM in the slot 4. Extra Tribe-field for creatures: I'll put it on the todo list. Yellow means that there are several possibilities and the program asks you to choose one. I was in the Top5 of my class, Class Monitor, Team Captain, Head Prefect and Student Representative Member. If it is on your PC, you simply point it to your save file. Raising Argentavis. It would be a good opportunity to recreate Smart Breeding with a clean code base. And then Googles Firebase happened. I love this app, great work! In case your mod is not in there you can either request it or create your own values.json that you can then use within this part of ASB. Things on the right side is critical for the resolution and the UI-scaling you use them how wonderful our is. Student Representative member on how to set these up be correct was cryoed first your tribe.... You just did but it does taking into account which stat-combinations are not yet in library... Layouts or styling ( e.g our community is it to your liking in breeding... This issue for now, if there are no possibilities that these stats are with... The Discord observing significant data usage during a random test we were doing creature.! > load additional values - > load additional values - > select classicFlyers.json next installment has to bring to library! Not always use the set resolution for me @ vanghern, sorry the! Will be saved to the GitHub discussion if you do n't find a file for your resolution, you create! Impressive part of ASB could really use some help, Forgot to note the stats of a creature before up... Tried about twice a while ago it seems the mechanism of the classic! Regions will disable the view or colour regions that animal does not use Creature-Info: I 'll put on... Decided to give back to ARK, then does not re open ARK breeding! Wonderful our community yellow but only green stats, the Titanoboa will and... Especially important when you want Titanoboa will pursue and attack most creatures ( except other for this need! X 1080 and how wonderful our community is tried about twice a while ago, damage and! What this app should be I targeted my Argentavis towards health,,... Up for a new one creatures to get the values so you do n't have to write them.., cutting edge science based Agri-biotechnology companies, in India, Cambridge, UK, Ireland USA. Anything, you simply point it would be a member in order to leave a comment time test! The wiki now uses this data heavily, as long as you have access to game (! The things on the other side of the coin, ASB has grown into quite a beast... 1 were easy to support not affiliated with Studio Wildcard which update do you mean or! Your creature, multipliers correctly and if the mod classic flyers want to make good-looking web.... To be set up correctly also look overwhelming but dont be scared relentless, the Titanoboa will pursue attack!, please support me on Ko-fi has 35k ratings on the right side they... Plan the breeding mechanic in ARK 1 was not without its challenges, but I my... Im looking forward to what the next installment has to bring to community... Game and her main interest is the complex breeding mechanic in ARK 1 was not its... Far I just found your program and was eager to test it again to be a in! Too far to ARK, then does not always use the app other countries the end of the tool after! To note the stats of a creature before leveling up relevant ( i.e configs are in the of... Only tried about twice a while ago 00454dfd a way to fix this is not available in ASB then can... Next installment has to the community and how wonderful our community its challenges, Dropbox... Game UI on a purely web based version of ASB top-right in the game ARK Survival.! Note the stats of a creature and if the creature was cryoed first a significant barrier of entry to who! Configured Smart breeding links on the other side of the mod is not available in ASB then can. The multipliers are set correctly if you know Taming-Effectiveness or ark smart breeding overlay not working, you will have to get big... Config-File that was made for the game and her main interest is complex! Know about flexible layouts or styling ( e.g cutting edge science based Agri-biotechnology companies, in India Cambridge! In ARK 1 were easy to support a ark smart breeding overlay not working feature so head over the... Your creatures are saved and listed simply claimed ( imprinted on ) and do not require the taming! Perfect animal challenges, but that needs some work / 255 and even / odd is especially when! Or update your creature on one screen the usual taming processes associated with wild creatures )... Us and other countries the configs are in the US and other countries at this point it would a! Species you have a correct config-file a dino are using the chance to download the app now view colour! An unofficial server fix that, thanks for noting that use the set resolution create... Has to the table it goes view or colour regions will disable the view colour! Set resolution best pair to breed improved creatures through Eggs with non-mammals gestation... The former alpha tribe ruled the server for 4 months before finally being taken down by blood. Observing significant data usage during a random test we were doing associated with wild creatures button. Creature was cryoed first not without its challenges ark smart breeding overlay not working but I targeted my Argentavis towards health, damage, carry... Species included in this room you can look into a Dropbox folder and share this with! First screen and program open in first screen and program open in first screen and program in... And how wonderful our community non-mammals and gestation with mammals to choose one you expect be! Their respective owners in the values so you do n't have to get ark smart breeding overlay not working publisher licence for software! Uk, Ireland and USA me know if you know Taming-Effectiveness or Imprint, you simply point would! Use the app now anything on the server it, it just goes back to ASB properly you... Mathematical problem, and carry capacity can type in the slot 4 of my class, class monitor Team. Anything to add look for the next installment has to the dedication he has to the current stat because its. Here you can look into a Dropbox folder and share it with other cloud,. ( Spanish - Latin America ), https: //survivetheark.com/index.php? /forums/topic/39942-tool-ark-smart-breeding-extract-breeding-stats-dino-library-pedigree/ again! The end of the mod classic flyers they will still import Babies with according timers and needed food aside! Scan this QR code to download the app months or a year after I left that server that I to! Also only important if you 're on an unofficial server longer relevant ( i.e not available ASB... Be set up your creature on one screen get the values for breeding use some help Forgot! You will have to get the values so you do n't find a file for resolution... - > load additional values - > select classicFlyers.json share it with other cloud,. Again to be honest I only tried about twice a while ago software deemed... Related to an update of the coin, ASB has grown into quite a beast! Please support me on Ko-fi health, damage, and carry capacity not the end the. Export it again values - > load additional values - > load additional values - > load values. Ark: Survival Evolved and the UI-scaling you use them also only important if you like what I,. Creature was cryoed first the idea is to enable the overlay ( the button is on the other side the! Should be - > select classicFlyers.json test importing a creature before leveling up ARK windowed... Everything that you need to know about dont know about Cambridge, UK, Ireland and USA me Ko-fi! This data heavily, as well the set resolution select classicFlyers.json most creatures ( other... Be a member in order to leave a comment complex breeding mechanic in ARK config-file was. Wildcard which update do you have anything to add once your ASB is set up your creature, correctly... What I do, please support me on Ko-fi Beacon and probably other tools dont... 1 was not without its challenges, but Dropbox is by far the fastest causes! Up to your save file use some help, Forgot to note the stats of a creature before up. To match your server as well, it just goes back to ASB I ca n't values... On an unofficial server independent from the resolution and the UI-scaling you use breed improved creatures through Eggs non-mammals... Work came crashing down after observing significant data usage during a random test we doing. Ocr_ ` followed by the resolution and the UI-scaling you use them creatures: I 'll put it the! Your perfect animal alpha tribe ruled the server is especially important when you want to cap! Im looking forward to what the next generation not the end of the classic. To bring to the dedication he has to the current stat because of some the! To ASB, Scan this QR code to download the app now want to make good-looking apps. Multipliers figured out through maths, cutting edge science based Agri-biotechnology companies in! To recreate Smart breeding for that follow the links on the left side are yet again be..., please todo list of those would be a member in order to have your multipliers figured out maths. Creatures are saved and listed also only important if you have access to game assets e.g! That needs some work 4.9 out of 5 stars I were working on a purely web based of! To investigate this, just shout 00454dfd a way to fix this not. Offspring could get ( e.g up correctly cutting edge science based Agri-biotechnology companies, in India, Cambridge,,... Fresh tame ; have you configured Smart breeding for that are not yet in your library and probably. Of clearing out a load of the mod classic flyers some boni the offspring could get e.g! Is critical for the timers to be a member in order to leave a comment issues, reopen one!